I have been working on t-shirt designs. The designs are basically the history of women in music on a shirt. And in research for one design about female folk musicians in the sixties Buffy Sainte-Marie, came up. I remembered there had been some scandal recently surrounding her music. Long story short, she claims native Cree heritage and built a very influential career on that history and culture. But it was called into question and she is being canceled by many, and having awards and recognition revoked. You can wade in that indigenous water if you want but personally I say skip it, it’s probably not your story to sort out.
As somebody who has dealt with trauma, I get really prickly when people- even well meaning people get offended on my behalf. It removes my agency and the fact that I have moved on from it and don’t need others to be mad for me or seek justice for me. I sorted it out myself, thank you. So I am not offended by her lies because I am not indigenous and never connected to her music from that angle to begin with. It is not my place or my story. Each person will come come to their own place in how they deal with it.
But this story reminded me that when I go out to my local club me and the coat check lady connect over a shared (though not serious) annoyance that Morrissey is a prima donna douche but people still play his music at the club and go to his shows. Now sure, Morrissey was one member of The Smiths so it was not just HIS music. Even so, with all the cancel culture going on he seems immune to it.
And every week I seem to come across some musician or actor being tossed in a ditch or thrown under a bus even if they have already been dead for decades. Recently I’ve read the hilarious efforts of people trying to rewrite rock history as if nobody every really liked Eric Clapton’s music or the man himself. And still pushing the lie that somehow he was responsible for his son’s death (he wasn’t even there when it happened). To say nothing of claiming things like, “He is an overrated no talent that nobody ever really respected.” Despite copious evidence otherwise, just start with B.B. King & Buddy Guy and go from there.
Also in the past couple months somebody told me we are no longer allowed to listen to Róisín Murphy or play her music at clubs or on the radio. This was news to me having just seen her live in the packed Warfield the year prior. And the show was like being at a queer club for two hours straight with ZERO breaks for any applause or costume changes. But having the directive pointed out to me I did my due diligence and checked to see what was up.
After some research I eye-rolled, not because being a TERF is a non issue (I was disappointed) but because in the grand scheme Róisín Murphy is just such a small fish in a pool of far worse people and dangers right now.
But with the information, I just started mentioning casually among friends how she was canceled. And most people went, “Who is that?” And those who knew her or knew her work with Moloko, basically just shrugged and went, “Well that sucks, (insert song here) is still a banger though.”
And I find whether it is Michael Jackson, The 1975, Crystal Castles, Nicki Minaj… cancel culture seems to exist mainly in a place called the internet. Where it is easy for people to shout and not take any real action. It doesn’t translate to the real world. And I think with music specifically this is because, to quote myself, “Great pop songs never die.”
“Sing It Back”, is still a total disco banger. Róisín being backed into a corner and going TERF doesn’t change that. Sorry.
Also in terms actual change to the systems in place harming trans people or other minorities the cancel culture movement, while well intentioned, has just became such a huge tsunami of names that after a point that most people just quit caring. I personally can think a few women in my friend circle who expressed just this sentiment at peak metoo. We discovered again that humans can be awful. And in the current social climate some people are learning some humans are far more awful than they thought.
Side note: Most people on this planet are lovely kind, if imperct souls. Period. We outnumber the true monsters is huge numbers. So just keep that in mind.
Now personally, my own position is cancel whoever/whatever you want. It is your choice. But don’t act like the morality police and demand other people tow your line. Sure, you can mention or inform people that “Hey, just so you know, so and so did X”. And the recipient of that information can go do their own research and make their own choices.
But the holier than thou a lot of people come at others with, can fuck right off. The being offended for other people to try and position yourself on the winning team can fuck right off. Because at the end of the day we are all hypocrites. WE ARE ALL hypocrites! We draw lines where it is convenient for us. And often we move the goal posts from one month to the next just keep from having nothing to enjoy.
So unless you are going to live in a cave alone and consume no media at all my suggestion is shut the fuck up. Make you personal choices for yourself but don’t go proselytizing like you are the last word on morals. I don’t actively try to support toxic people or systems and when informed do make my own judgments and sometimes those judgments do not align with mob mentality, usually because I did research that led to a nuanced take.
I have two personal examples.
Bill Cosby was a hero of mine. His stand-up special Cosby Himself informed my sense of humor and how I view the world from a very young age. The fact that the special starts with a bit about going to the dentist and my father was a dentist was a bonus.
I also liked that he tried to bring communities up and gave me as a white kid an opposing view of black culture compared to what was shown in many movies and on the news and certainly in the 90s on MTV. He seemed to value intellect and intelligence. And now I think most people know the story. And I made my choice and I remember my mother responding to my choice by saying, “Well I can absolutely believe that many women would get together to destroy one very good man. I’ve seen it myself.” We all draw our lines and we all have our truths. More on truths in a moment.
But even with the choice I made for myself, Cosby Himself is still funny. It will always be funny to me because while Cosby was a monster he was also funny. And that special spoke the truth about many subjects. Now I am not actively seeking out his material anymore. I’m certainly not directly giving him any of my money by buying his products. But I can’t change history and be unaffected or uninformed by his comedy. And even if I could it would make me a lesser version of the self I am today.
My second example is one I seem to wrestle with even more than Cosby because the story is even more relatable to my own, and that is Woody Allen. Woody Allen’s films have been a very important part of my identity in so many ways.
Since his films were important to me and since I am a survivor of child sexual abuse I have done too much research on the Woody and Mia marriage, case, trials, testimonies etc. to try and figure out where I stand and how that might or might not effect effect my own recovery.
And I can tell you from personal experience truth is tricky. I related to the story because I had siblings and two very toxic parents. I have my truth about the abuse that happened to me in the family and I know that truth does not match other people’s truths in my own family. It is why I had to shut them out from my life entirely. So I will say upfront that I respect the truths of all the children involved with Woody and Mia. And I respect the truth from Woody’s fully adult wife and the fact that their marriage has outlasted most in Hollywood and elsewhere.
The people continuing to be publicly angry and offended on behalf of others who have already spoken their truth can fuck off. It is not your place to position yourself as a character in someone else’s story with your outrage, dictating how you think they should feel or act.
Side note: If you are still up in arms over some old man celebrity like Woody Allen or whoever, to where it is taking up any part of your life… uh… go check a mirror. Or as the kids say, “touch grass”. Seriously, you are letting a person who you don’t personally know and supposedly detest take up space in your mind and spirit. Why? There are far too many wonderful people and things outside your door to be wasting those precious seconds on people you hate. Hate is a waste of time.
Now if you want to cancel Woody Allen or Mia Farrow or both fine. Do it and shut up. Don’t come at me, ya hypocrite. Especially, those who don’t even have the facts right.
But if you do bravely (or naively) decide to come at me, I’m going to immediately respond with, “So, I assume you also canceled every actor he ever worked with and will not be watching any of their films anymore either. Or other director’s who still support his work. That is a long roster of people. How far down the hole are you willing to slide with your sanctimonious orating?”
Again the point here is we all draw our lines where we choose to. So don’t judge me for where I draw mine with your arbitrary morality test.
Anyway, I spent enough time doing my own research with the news stories and all the various documentaries and interviews and I decided, yup, Annie Hall is still one of my favorite films of all time. Sleeper and Small Time Crooks are still two of the funniest films I have ever seen. Midnight In Paris, Everyone Says I Love You, Blue Jasmine… still great. Match Point? Maaaaannnnn that may be one of his best of all time for me. Tabloid tales aside, Woody Allen is one the greatest filmmakers of all time, period.
Side note: Musical poster child for peace and love Rastafarian, Bob Marley, was sexist and terrible to women. There I have informed you. Do what you will with that info.
Phew!
With that out of the way I want to offer up a hopefully helpful way for you personally to deal with this issue we often refer to as, “Separating the art from the artist”. In my travels on the internet globe seeing people’s reactions to problematic people saying I can’t listen to X musician or watch Y films ever again. It is all very sad to me.
Sad, because that mindset is letting the asshole win. They already made their money (maybe millions) off the work. They are not going to suffer financially and may never be brought to justice, whatever than means in this day and age. They may never stop being an asshole. So don’t let these demons ruin something that changed your life.
If the Harry Potter series shaped your youth forever, you can’t unshape it. So don’t let Rowling take that from you!
Once she released those books they stopped being owned by her. They became yours in your own personal way. So reread them if you want, watch the films. Go to Harry Potter themed parties… The same with Róisín Murphy or whoever is on the chopping block. And don’t let the mob mentality get to you. Think critically for yourself and make the choice for yourself and don’t judge others for their choices.
When metoo was in full swing so many names kept coming up left and right that I ultimately decided, I will allow myself a mere five slots in my life for actively canceling a celebrity or the like. Five slots. The people in those slots can and have changed over time. For example Cosby is so canceled in my life that he doesn’t get to take up a spot anymore. In the same way the Apricot Adolf was always so canceled in my life he moved to the front of the line and was never even honored with a spot to begin with. I settled my connections with Cosby and have moved on from his comedy as I have other things to give my attention to. But, Cosby Himself… still funny and brilliant comedy. It just is.
And to bring it back to Buffy Sainte-Marie here is a quote from Cree author Michelle Good from the Commontion podcast on the matter that I think say in one short paragraph what took me a whole page of verbose writing.
“I think people are responding as though the whole thing was a lie, but when you stood in a concert with Buffy going wild, with her amazing music and her amazing presentation, your feeling was real. That was real. You don’t have to give up that feeling that you had, you don’t have to give up your admiration for the talent, and for the encouragement that she gave Indigenous people. . . . Buffy has some work to do in terms of sorting this all out, but we don’t.”
I agree you don’t have to sort out how the music or the movies or books changed your life they changed you, period, and for the better. Leave the rest of the mess in the trash bin where it belongs or in the history texts as examples of what not to do.

















